Comparison

Consentico vs CookieYes

Both are competent CMPs. Consentico is the cleaner choice for Shopify-only operators; CookieYes is the better pick if you also run WordPress, Webflow, or other platforms and want one CMP across all of them.

Where Consentico wins

  • Built specifically for Shopify — theme app extension, Customer Privacy API sync, no script snippet to paste.
  • Half the price at the Pro tier, with a more useful free tier (5,000 banner views with full features vs limited features at any volume).
  • Settings live entirely in the Shopify admin; no second dashboard to manage.
  • Three-layer script blocking (createElement override + MutationObserver + type=text/plain) — actually blocks trackers, doesn't just record consent.
  • Per-cookie disclosure auto-generated from a real Puppeteer scan of your storefront.

Where CookieYes wins

  • Cross-platform — runs identically on Shopify, WordPress, Webflow, Wix, and custom HTML sites.
  • Established product with thousands of reviews and a long track record.
  • Larger global cookie database for automatic categorisation.
  • More extensive documentation and community resources.

Feature-by-feature comparison

FeatureConsenticoCookieYes
Free tier5,000 views/mo, all features25,000 visitors, limited features
Cheapest paid plan$7.99/mo$10/mo
Shopify-native install

Both via theme app embed

Configuration in Shopify admin

CookieYes config is on cookieyes.com

Three-layer script blocking
Google Consent Mode v2
GPC honouring
Geo-targeting (EU-only)Pro and aboveHigher tiers only
Cookie scannerUp to 500 pages (Business)Up to 100 pages on paid plans
Consent log CSV exportPro and aboveHigher tiers only
Custom CSSBusinessHigher tiers
Remove brandingBusiness ($16.99/mo)Premium ($55+/mo)
Languages supported830+
IAB TCF v2.2

Matters only if you sell ad inventory

Try Consentico free

Free for stores under 5,000 banner views per month. Five-minute install, no theme edits, no credit card.

Join the waitlistSee pricing

See more comparisons: all alternatives